Not Just Playing Pretend

Posted on November 16, 2026
Word Count: 778

Comments 0

A comment from the discussion group on Saturday snagged in me. I don’t remember the exact words, I don’t remember quite the exact context, I just remember it was about how we pretend.

And you know. It’s a valid perspective. That’s precisely what some people do. They imagine, they set up scenarios, they role play, they pretend.

I don’t. And while I call Tim my owner, I don’t mean it in a pretend way. Sure, I don’t mean it in a legal sense, but within the scope of our constructed relationship.

I have given him enormous authority over my life. Just because it’s constructed and consented to does not make it any less real. Doubly so, since we’ve gone to the extent of legal paperwork allowing him to talk on my behalf in medical situations. I’m always legally allowed to override him in those situations, but that doesn’t make the authority pretend, considering a medical professional has to accept his word in my stead if I’m not contradicting him.

And that’s our entire relationship structure. I’m always allowed to withdraw consent, but at that point, due to how deep we’ve gone with this structure, I would be dismantling our dynamic; we’d be at a renegotiation stage if I chose to do so. And I can. We’ve had those discussions. I love to point out to people that I can always withdraw consent and we can renegotiate. He’s been very clear with me that we could still have a dynamic without it being as deep as we’ve gone, and if I really wanted out, we could even still have a relationship without the dynamic. I wouldn’t lose my life partner for wanting to back down. I like to point that out because so many dynamics exist in a “take it or leave it” state, and I think there’s an element of coercion there. Which… is not what this post is about and I’ve gone off on a tangent.

So I could renegotiate, but does that make it pretend? I don’t believe so. You can break up with your partner; does that make your relationship pretend? You can get a divorce; does that make your marriage pretend? You can quit your job (whether it’s a good idea or not); does that make your work agreement pretend? There are a lot of constructed situations in life. If you want to go to the logical extremes and call all of these things playing pretend, then sure, what I do in D/s is pretend, too.

But no one’s really pushing on that the way people seem to be wanting to push on D/s being pretend.

I don’t believe that’s what this person was saying. I don’t think that was the angle—that all of this is pretend. But I’ve run into people online who definitely thought that. And my arguing with them largely didn’t go anywhere.

There are lots and lots of kinksters who do put a lot of effort into playing pretend—I’ll give you that. People that set up elaborate scenarios in the bedroom—sure if they want to call that pretend, it probably is. Role play is, by definition, pretend. Going to a party and assuming a role for the evening may very well be pretending for an evening.

But lifestylers… some may feel like they’re pretending, but it’s hard to say it’s pretend when it’s literally your day-to-day life.

No one seems to be arguing that being hit with a cane is pretend. The physical sensations are real. The headspace you can get into is real. But something about explicitly giving one partner authority over the other in a relationship seems to make people uncomfortable.

I think it’s honestly one more saying that’s going around designed to make what I do more palatable for those on the outside. It’s safer if they think it’s just playing pretend. Because we, as kinksters, are on the outskirts. And I’m seeing us slowly integrating more into the media in a positive normal way, so society at large seems to be allowing more and more that we exist. But people on both sides—inside the kink community and outside the kink community—seem to want to make what we do more palatable for those on the outside. We want to be understood rather than ostracized, and this is one way of doing that.

I don’t care to make my life palatable for anyone.

I’m sorry, but I’m not pretending here. I’ve internalized this. This is my reality. It’s scoped. Tim’s authority is within the scope of our relationship. But it’s still very real.

I give him the authority. He uses it. And we’re happy inside our little structure we built together.

Comments

There are currently no comments on this article.

Comment

Enter your comment below. Fields marked * are required. You must preview your comment before submitting it.